A breakthough, an epiphany! It seems like I dont have to be recording at all to write parameter automation, this is all new to me! Another thing that was pretty weird was that although the VSTi had automatically mapped the controller, and it's set to midi channel 5 (along with my controller), I had to 'learn' the CC's from Reaper's automation list, and when I turn the knob, Reaper thinks it's actually channel 4 CC's... Anyone have any ideas why?